180 The Strand, 3049, 424, A Rehearsal in Language, About Text, Absolutely Cultured, Act of Creation, Adrian Edwards, Advertising, Advertising is the Folk Art of the 20th Century, AHRC, AHRC Open World Research Initiative, Aimee Selby, Ainslie Roddick, Alighiero Boetti, All of Them Loved, All We Have is Worlds, Alphabet, Amanda Beech, Ami Clarke, Analema, Andrea Lissoni, Andrew Durbin, Andrew Lister, Andrew Walsh Lister, Andrey Shental, Andy Wicks, Anglia Ruskin University, Animal Communication, Anita Zabludowicz, Anna Barham, Anna Longo, Annette Jael Lehmann, Anthony Discenza, Anthropology, Anti-Book, Appius & Virginia, Archaeology, Architectural Acoustics, Archive, Aristotle’s Poetics, Art & Language, Art and Writing, Art Blocks, Art Language Location, Artforum, Arthur Koestler, Artichoke, Artichoke Trust, Artificial Language, Arts & Humanities Research Council, Atau Tanaka, Audio Inkblot, Audio Rorschach, Auditory Inkblot, Auditory Neuroscience, Auditory Projective Test, Auditory Rorschach, Aura Satz, Autosuggestions, Axis, Banner Repeater, BBC Four, BBC4, Beate Gartner, Beatrice Catanzaro, Beautiful Language, Beautiful Meme, Ben Bacon, Benjamin Bacon, Between The Ear and the Mouth, Between the Lines, Between the Lines – Maddox Gallery, Between the Lines – Maddox Street, Beware of Linguistic Engineering, BFTK, Bibliomancy, Bill Kouligas, Bloomsbury, Bloomsbury Festival, Bomb Magazine, Bonds, Booklyn, Bookworks, Bournemouth Light, Branding, Branding should be regarded as the contemporary equivalent of folk art, Brandon LaBelle, Breath, Breathe, Brecht De Man, Brian Dillon, Bricks from the Kiln, Bridget Riley, Brigitte Kowanz, British Library, British Museum, Brody Neuenschwander, Bruce Nauman, Bulldog Trust, C.W. Morris, C4i, California Institute of the Arts, Cambridge Archaeological Journal, Cambridge Assessment, Cambridge School of Art, Cambridge Triangle, Carroll & Fletcher, Case Foundation, Castle, Castle Art, Castle Fine Art, Castle Galleries, Castor, Castor Projects, Cause & Effect, Cavalli Sforza, Cave Leeds, Cave Painting, CCA, CCA Glasgow, Center for Discursive Inquiry, Centre for Audio Visual Experimentation, Centre for Contemporary Art, Centre for Contemporary Arts, Centre for Modern and Contemporary Writing, Centre Point, Cerith, Cerith Wynn, Cerith Wynn Evans, Channel Somerset House, Channels, Charing Cross Road, Charles Darwin, Charles W. Morris, Chateau Denmark, Chelsea College of Arts, Cheyney Thompson, Chicago Review, Chisenhale, Chisenhale Dance Space, Chisenhale Gallery, Chris Bracey, Christian Boltanski, Christine Kim Sum, Christy MacLear, Colin Cherry, Collecting the Alphabet, Colour of Sound, Colour Semiotic, Colour Semiotics, Communication, Company Gallery, Conceptual Art, Concrete Poetry, Constellations of Listening, Contemporary Art, Contemporary Art Museum St. Louis, Contemporary Philosophy of Technology Research Group, Contemporary Writing, Continent, Creativity, Creativity Gene, CRISAP, Crisap LCC, Cultural History, Cultural History of the Ghost, Cuneiform, Curandi Katz, Curating Writing, Dalhousie University, Damion Searls, Dan Flavin, Daniel Birnbaum, Daniel Keller, Daniel Sacilotto, Danni Zuvela, Daria Martin, David Gates, David Hockney, David Roberts Art Foundation, David Sington, David Toop, Dayanita Singh, Deep Structure, Delaine Le Bas, Denmark Street, Dev Joshi, Developmental Verbal Dyspraxia, Dick Bracey, Different Languages Same Place, Dimensions of Language, Discord, Discord Server, Disinformation, Disinformation Art, Disinformation Art Project, Disinformation Artist, Disinformation Artist Project, Disinformation Artist's Project, Divine Language, DNA, Domo Baal, Donatien Grau, Dr Sarah Hayden, Dr. Jason Haslam, Drury Lane, Durham, Durham University, DVD, Dynamics of Language, Ear and Mouth, Ear and the Mouth, Early Writing, Earwitness Theatre, Echo, Electric City, Electric City Leadenhall Market, Electricity The Spark of Life, Emily Jacir, Emma Bolland, Emma Harrison, Emma Wolukau-Wanambwa, English Forecast, Enjoy Civic Life, Enlighten Manchester, Entropics, Erica Scourti, Erick Beltran, Es Devlin, Es Devlin - Music Language and Light, Esther Venrooij, Evans, Everything at Once, Evolution, Evolutionary Biology, Evolutionary Linguistics, Ewan Clayton, Experimental Writing, Expert Horror, Fabien Giraud, Fayd, Fayd Digital, Ferruccio Rossi-Landi, Festival, Festival of Light & Sound Art, Fiat Lux, Field of Vision, Fieldnotes, Fieldnotes Journal, Fieldnotes/Sessions, Finkel, Flora Yin-Wong, Florian Hecker, Florian Ortkass, Folk Art, Forkhead Box P2, Forkhead Box Protein, Forkhead Box Protein P2, Fossil Record, FOXP2, FOXP2 Antibody, FoxP2 Gene, FOXP2 Protein, Francis McKee, Frédéric Grossi, Freedom of Speech, Freie Universität Berlin, Frieze, Frieze Academy, Frieze Magazine, Future City, Future Pace, Future Self, Futurecity, Future\Pace, Gabriel Whaley, Galerie Thaddaeus Ropac, Gallery 31, Gascia Ouzounian, Gauld Architecture, Gazell.io, Gazell.io Project Space, Gazelli, Gazelli Art House, Gazellio, Gazello Art House, Gæoudjiparl van den Dobbelsteen, George Hallett, Georgia Stephenson, Ghost in the Machine, Giorgio Borrelli, God's Own Junkyard, Gold SF, Goldsmiths, Goldsmiths CCA, Goldsmiths Centre for Contemporary Arts, Goldsmiths College, Goldsmiths Press, Goldsmiths Press - Sonics Series, Goldsmiths Press Sonics, Goldsmiths Shorts, Goodiepal, Goodiepal Equation, Grammar, Grammar Gene, Grammatology, Grundy Art Gallery, Gulf of Understanding, Hana Noorali, Hanna Tuulikki, Hannes Koch, Harvard University, Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Haus der Kulturen der Welt Berlin, Hayward Gallery, Hegemony, Helen Marriage, Heloise Reynolds, Here at Outernet, Heresy, Hermann Rorschach, Hieroglyphics, History of Writing, HKW, HKW Berlin, Hockney, Holy Bible, Hugh Sington, Hull, Human Conversation, Human Genome, Humber Street, Humber Street Gallery, Humber Street Hull, Hush: Media and Sonic Self Control, Hypebeast, Hypersonica, I Have A Voice, Ilan Manouache, Illuminating Gas, Illuminations Archive, IMCC Westminster, Immersive Soundscape, In the beginning was the Word, Independent Researcher, Industrial Language, Inflamed Invisible, Information as Material, Infrasonica, Inigo Wilkins, Inspired by Language, Institute for Modern and Contemporary Cultures, Institute of Modern Art Brisbane, Institute of Signals and Noise, International, International Lawns, International Media Futures, International MediaFutures, Intertitles, Ioana Cerasella Chis, Irving, Irving Finkel, Jack Smurthwaite, Jacqueline Humphries, Jacques Derrida, James Mansell, James Stam, James Turrell, James Wiltgen, Jamie XX, Jason Haslam, Jeffrey Schnapp, Jeremy Deller, Jerwood Arts, Jess Chandler, Jini Reddy, Jo Barratt, Joe Banks, Joel Stern, Johanna Schindler, John 1:1, John Dennis, John Hansard Gallery, John Reardon, John Tavener, Jonathan Monk, Jonathon Carroll, Joseph Kosuth, Julien Breton, Juun J, Kader Attia, Kadist, Katerina Chuchalina, Kathleen Forde, Katrin Klingan, Katy Wan, Keh Ng, Keira Greene, Ken Hollings, Kerris Casey St Pierre, Kim Albrecht, Kim Schoen, Kornhausforum Bern, La Maison Rouge, Language, Language Acts, Language Acts and Worldmaking, Language Acts and Worldmaking Project, Language and its Possible Worlds, Language and Light, Language and Perception, Language and Possible Worlds, Language and Sound, Language Art, Language as a Material, Language as a Medium, Language as Material, Language as Medium, Language as Technology, Language Based Art, Language Circuits, Language Describing Sound, Language Experiment, Language for Sale, Language Game[s], Language Gene, Language is a Virus, Language is a Virus from Outer Space, Language is Memory, Language is Meta-Technology, Language is MetaTechnology, Language is the technology that contains all others, Language Poetry, Language Processing, Language Tech, Language Technology, Language Transitions, Language [as] Meta-Technology, Language [as] Metatechnology, Lascaux and Altamira, Late Night Chameleon Cafe, Laure Prouvost, Lawrence Abu Hamdan, Leadenhall Market, Leaky Transmissions, Leeloo, Leo Fitzmaurice, Leontine Coelewij, Let There be Language, Let there be Light, Let's Talk, Let's Talk About Text, Lexis, Lexis/Axis, Library X, Light Art, Light Festival, Light Festivals, Light Installation, Light Night, Light Night Leeds, Light Night Liverpool, Light Poems, Light Roller, Light Room, Light Up, Light Up Blackburn, Light Up Lancaster, Light Up The North, Light Waves, Lightning, Lightroom, Lights of Soho, Lightwaves, Lilt Twang Tremor, Linguistic Engineering, Lins Derry, Liquid Architecture, Liquid Language, Lisson Gallery, Listening Academy, Listening Biennial, Listening Challenge, Literary Arts, Literature, Liverpool, Liza Sylvestre, LN-CC, London, London College of Communication, London Review Bookshop, London Science Museum, London Southbank, Lower Third, Luigi Luca Cavalli Sforza, Luma Arles, Lumiere, Lumiere Durham, Lumiere London, LUTN, Lydia Wilson, Lynton Talbot, Mack Hagood, MAD Museum, Maddox Gallery, Magda Romanska, Makiko Yamamoto, Making Your Mark, Manick Govinda, Manifesto of Perception, Many Voices, Many Voices All of Them Loved, Marc Glimcher, Marc-Olivier Wahler, Marco Brambilla, Margot Mottaz, Marguerite Humeau, Marie José Burki, Mark Alizart, Mark Coeckelbergh, Marshall McLuhan, Martin de la Fouchardière, Material Symbolic, Material Symbolic and Signal Inscriptions, Matthew Stock, Matthew Stuart, Mature Themes, Maurizio Nannucci, Media and Sonic Self Control, Media Futures, MediaFutures, Melissa Dickson, Meme, Memetics, Memory of Sound, Meta Lab Berlin, Meta Lab FU Berlin, Meta Lab Harvard, Meta-Tech, Meta-Technology, Metalab, Metalab Berlin, Metalab FU Berlin, Metalab Harvard, Metatech, Metatechnology, Michael Erdman, Michael Petry, Michał Łojewski, Mircea Cantor, Misinformation, Misplaced Memories, Misplaced Words, MIT Press, MOCA London, Modern Language, Modern Language Experiment, Moderni Kanuuna, Mollie Dent-Brocklehurst, Mondriaan Fund, MondriaanFund, Morten Christiansen, Mounir Fatmi, MSCHF, MSCHF art collective, Museum of Arts & Design, My Bookcase, Nahmad Contemporary, Nathan Gray, Natural Language, Natural Language Processing, Nature Morte, Near Bliss Index, Neon, Neon Man, Neon Sculpture, Neon Sign, Neon: The Charged Line, Neurogenesis, Nic Joly, Nick Houde, Nick Ryan, Nick Thurston, Nicolas Consuegra, Nicole Bachmann, Nicoline van Harskamp, Nightboat Books, Nike, No Field of Vision, No Realm of Thought, No Realm of Thought… No Field of Vision, Noam Chomsky, Nottingham Contemporary, Now Arcade, Now Building, Now Pop-Up, Now Pop-Up 2, Now Trending, Now You're Talking, Occasional Papers, Of Grammatology, OOMK, Open World Research Initiative, Oral Tradition, Origin of Species, Origin of Writing, Ours Magazine, Outernet, Outernet Arts, Outernet Global, Outernet Live, Outernet London, Oxford Street, P-A-N, Pace, Pace Discord, Pace Gallery, Pace Gallery Discord, Pace Live, Pace London, Pace Verso, Palais de Tokyo, Palgrave, Pan, Parl Kristian Bjørn Vester, Parrhesiades, Passen–gers Offsite, Passengers Offsite, Patten, Paul Pettitt, Pedagogies of the Ear, Pedro Neves Marques, Personare, Pete Belkin, Peter Dalton, Peter Toth, Phenomenology of Perception, PhilofTech, Phonetics, Phonogram, Phonograph, Piero Golia, Pierre Lanchantin, Pixel Artworks, Play Back Play, Poetry, Poetry Film and Technology in the 21st Century, Poetry Foundation, Poetry of Radio, Poetry Project, PoetryFilm, Political Effects of Listening, Politics of Communication, Politics of Listening, Porta 33, Porta33, Possible Worlds, Primer, Printed Heritage, Printed Heritage Collections, Project Space, Projection Artworks, Projection Artworks Ltd, Proto-Language, Prototype Publishing, Psycholinguistics, Publication Studio Glasgow, Pump House Gallery, Pure Creation, Quays Culture, Quaysculture, Queen Mary University of London, Quinn Latimer, Radio Art Zone, Radio Arts Catalyst, Radio Silence, Radiophrenia, Raf Simons, Raina Mehler, Random, Random International, Raphael Siboni, Re: Cognition, Reading as Art, Reading Matters, Realm of Thought, Rebecca Lamarche-Vadel, Recognition, Red Crayola, Reference Studios, Reference Studios x Selfridges, Resonance FM, Richard Dawkins, Robert Montgomery, Robert Mott, Roberta Tenconi, Robin Mackay, Rogue Syntax, Rogue Syntax: Primer, Romantic Tragedy, Ron Sillimian, Room To Breathe, Rorschach Audio, Rosemary Richards, Rosetta Stone, Rothschild Foundation, Routledge, Rubin Museum of Art, Rural College of Art, Ruskin Gallery, Ryoji Ikeda, Sadie Coles, Sadie Coles HQ, Salford Quays, Sam Belinfante, Sami Sanpakkila, Sarah Coop, Sarah Derat, Sarah Hayden, Sarah Newman, Sarah Peace, Sarah Rose, SARU Goldsmiths, Scarlett Schauerte, School of Critical Studies, Scripting Silence, Scritlock’s Door, Scritti Politti, Scritto’s Republic, Sean Dockray & Benjamin Forster, Sean Street, Secret History, Secret History of Writing, Seeds of Thought, Self Expression, Selfridges, Semiology, Semionaut, Semionautic, Semionautics, Semiotext/e, Semiotexte, Semiotics, Semiotics Signs and Language, Semiotics Signs Language, Serpentine Gallery, Shannon Ebner, Shaping Space with Sound, She Bends, She Who Loves Silence, Sheena Calvert, Shelter Press, Shine, Shine Bursary, Sighs Trapped by Liars, Sign, Sign Systems, Signal Inscriptions, Signs and Language, Signs of Life, Simon & Schuster, Simon Kirby, Slip Tongue, Slow Compression, Sluice HQ, Sociotype, Sociotype Journal, SODA Gallery, Sofie van de Velde, Somerset House, Somerset House Channel, Somerset House Studios, Sonar Festival, Sonic Agency, Sonic Arcade, Sonic Art, Sonic Art Research Unit, Sonic Futures, Sonic Imaginaries, Sonic Inkblot, Sonic Lecture, Sonic Rorschach, Sonic Self Control, Sonic Studies, Sonic Writing, Sonic Writing Technologies, Sonic Writing Technologies of Material Symbolic and Signal Inscriptions, Sonics, Sonics Series, Sound Art, Sound Art Radio, Sound Design, Sound Emulating Language, Sound Poetics, Sound Poetry, Sound Recording Technology, Sound Studies, Sound Studies Journal, Sound Talking, Sound Text, Sound Text Image, Sound-Image, Sounding Things Out, Southbank Centre, Speculative Libraries, Speech, Speech and Language, Speech Itself is an Art Form, Stealing My Thunder, Stephanie Sherman, Stephen Bayley, Steve Fletcher, Steven Pinker, Store Studios, Store X, Stuart Wood, Super Blue, Superblue, Susan Hiller, Susan Owens, Susannah Stark, Swimmers, Synthetic Statistics, Systems, TAGS: The House that Heals the Soul, Takashi Murakami, Talk About Text, Tate Modern, Tate Publishing, Technology and Perception, Technology as Language, Temporary Services, Tenderpixel, Tenderpixel Gallery, Test Centre, Text Art, Texte Zur Kunst, Thaddaeus Ropac, Thames & Hudson, The Act of Creation, The Age of Creation, The Beautiful Language, The Beautiful Meme, The Book Lovers, The Bulldog Trust, The Ear and the Mouth, The Earliest Form of Sound Recording Technology was not a Machine but was Written Language, The Electric Comma, The Electronic Revolution, The Fifth Element, The Future of Listening, The Ghost, The Ghost - A Cultural History, The Ghost in the Machine, The Goodiepal Equation, The Gulf of Understanding, The Gulf of Understanding (Re:cognition), The History of Mankind, The Illuminating Gas, The Inkblots, The MIT Press, The Modern Language Experiment, The Now Building, The Optical Delusion Of Consciousness, The Origin of Language, The Origin of Painting, The Origin of Writing, The Power of Electricity, The Science of Signs, The Search for the Perfect Language, The Secret History of Writing, The Selfish Gene, The Serving Library, The Space Oracle, The Ticket That Exploded, The Vinyl Factory, The Voice as a Political Implement, The Voice of God, The Wail that was Warning, The White Review, The Wild Boys, The Word is Art, The World Is Sound, Theatre Sound, Theophany, Thor Magnusson, Thunder, Thunder Sheet, Tim Etchells, Tim Etchells - All We Have is Worlds, Tim Etchells - We Wanted, Today Art Museum, Tomato, Tony Tremlett, Tool Use, Tower of Babel, Tracey Emin, Translation Acts, Transmission, Transmissions, Transmitters and Receivers, Trevor Cox, Trevor Paglen, Triple Canopy, Turbine Festival, Ubi Sunt, UCL Hub, UEG, Umberto Eco, Underbelly, Undergraduate Journal of Literary Criticism, Underworld, Undone in the Face, Unit, Unit for Sound Practice Research, Unit Gallery London, Unit London, Unit London Gallery, United Visual Artists, University of Birmingham, University of Oxford, University of Southampton, University of Westminster, Unknown Tongues, Unnatural Language Processing, Unseen Presence, Unsound, Unsound Festival, Urban Fauna Lab, Urbanomic, Urbanomic Press, Usa e Guetta, UVA, V-A-C Foundation, Valentin Fetisov, Verso, Verso Journal, Verso: An Undergraduate Journal of Literary Criticism, Vinyl Factory, Visible Language, Visual Editions, Visual Semantics, Visual Semiotics, Vitrine, Vitrine Gallery, Viviana Checchia, Viviana Troya, Voice & How To Hear It, Voice Recognition, Voiceover, Voiceover as an Art-Form, Voiceover as an ArtForm, Voices in the Gallery, Voicing the Political, VRHAM Hamburg, Waddesdon Manor, Wade Guyton, Wade Wallerstein, We Wanted, Weapon, Weapons, Wellcome Trust, Where Art Meets Literature, White Cube, Whitstable Biennale, Why Brands Matter, Wild Boys, Will Be, Willem de Rooij, William Burroughs, Winter Light, Witte de With, Witte de With Center for Contemporary Art, Word and Image Studies, Word is Art, Word Power, WordPower - Language as Medium, Words and Worlds, Words and Worlds in William Burroughs The Wild Boys, Words Words Words, Writing, Writing and Concepts, Writing Making Your Mark, Written Language, Wynn, Wynn Evans, Yamamoto Keiko Rochaix, Zabludowicz, Zabludowicz Collection, Zata Banks
Let There Be Language – a short talk at Anglia Ruskin University, 18 Oct 2016
The following text is the transcript of a short talk presented at Anglia Ruskin University, 18 Oct 2016. The text includes 3 paragraphs found elsewhere on this website, however, rather than providing links to the earlier paragraphs, then asking readers to jump backwards and forwards between different posts, it seemed more sensible to provide the entire script of this talk, for the sake of continuity and uninterrupted reading. Those visitors who are already familiar with the earlier paragraphs are asked to read on through to find the newest material. Thanks to everyone who came along to the talk…
There is a perception, particularly among contemporary art critics and commentators, but also among members of the public, that sonic art is a relatively new art form; of course the truth is that sounds produced by voices are among the earliest materials ever subjected to any form of creative manipulation. Speech itself is an art-form, and therefore poetry and literature of the oral tradition are, alongside music, the oldest forms of sonic art, and probably in fact the oldest art-forms. On that basis it can be argued that far from being a marginal or in any way “difficult” art-form, sonic art is instead the most primal, the most pervasive, and arguably the earliest form of creative art, ever. The argument put forward in the book “Rorschach Audio – Art & Illusion for Sound”, is that, paraphrasing Aristotle’s “Poetics”, since written language is based on symbolic visual representations of indivisible sounds, the earliest form of sound recording technology was not therefore, as is generally presumed, any form of machine, but was in fact written language. Alongside poetry and literature of the oral tradition, even written literature and poetry are therefore forms of sound art. So, when one considers music, poetry, literature, theatre dialogue, theatre sound effects and architectural acoustics, and particularly also sound design for contemporary cinema and computer games, it can be argued that, in its various diverse and widespread manifestations, sonic art is one of, if not the most mainstream and commercially important of cultural commodities.
By way of just one illustration, the art of designing theatre sound effects is for instance quite clearly a form of sonic art, which goes back at least as far as those architects whose expertise ensured that the proverbial pin could be heard dropping throughout the auditoria of ancient Greek amphitheatres. As regards specifically British theatre, the historian Robert Mott describes how since “Shakespearian days” a “popular” method for creating illusions of thunder in theatre shows involved “a cannon-ball rolling down a trough and falling onto a huge drum”. Robert Mott states that “some people were not pleased with this cumbersome technique”, so, in 1708, the dramatist John Dennis designed a thunder effect for his play “Appius & Virginia” in Drury Lane. John Dennis “invented something more realistic and controllable – a large piece of thin copper sheeting suspended from a frame by wires”. “The thunder sheet was a great success, and as a result other stage productions began using his effect. This infuriated Dennis to the point where he would angrily confront the offending producer by charging ‘you, Sir, are stealing my thunder’.” Dennis is also said to have stated that “that is my thunder, by God; the villains will play my thunder, but not my play”. What this anecdote provides is not just another example of “early” sound art – of sonic art that predates contemporary fine-arts practice by 200 years – but also potentially the earliest recorded instance of what amounts to an intellectual property dispute between sound artists. This dispute was in fact so important that the phrase “stealing my thunder” has, for hundreds of years since, been immortalised as a very common figure-of-speech in the English language.
As you can all see, “The Act of Creation” is a collaborative neon sign artwork, created by myself and by Zata Banks. Genesis 1:3 states “Let there be Light”, while however John 1:1 states “in the beginning was the Word”. The philosopher, originally engineer and psychologist, Charles W. Morris defined semiotics as “the science of signs”; so, analysed in terms of visual semiotics, “The Act of Creation” is an artwork which articulates a message that’s implicit in all neon signs – namely the association between illumination and language; and, in articulating the phrase “Let There Be Language”, “The Act of Creation” is unique among neon sign artworks in the depth of integration between medium and message, since it’s light itself that literally and metaphorically illuminates the nature of the play on words.
As described in his book “The Search for the Perfect Language”, the novelist and semiotician Umberto Eco, described how “our story has an advantage over many others, [since] it can begin at the beginning”. Eco goes on to describe how “God spoke before all things… [God] said, let there be light. In this way [God] created both heaven and earth, for, with the utterance of the divine word, there was light… Creation itself arose through an act of speech”. Eco describes how, in Genesis 2:16-17 “the Lord speaks to man for the first time, putting at his disposal all the goods in the earthly paradise, commanding him, however, not to eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge”. Umberto Eco continues “we are not told in what language God spoke to Adam. Tradition has pictured it as a sort of language of interior illumination, in which God… expresses himself by thunderclaps and lightning” [1]; this theme forms the subject matter of one of the earlier sonic artworks I’ve created – which is a recording of radio noise produced by lightning strikes during an electrical storm, a recording entitled “Theophany” – “the Voice of God” – which was published on LP in 1996 [2].
As regards the origin of language, the scriptural, ie – religious, provenance of these anecdotes is potentially misleading however… they shouldn’t be dismissed as simple fantasies, because mythological stories have considerable anthropological, arguably archaeological, significance. As what amounts to a kind of fossil record of early human thought, Biblical passages show early writers testing hypotheses not only about the act of creation, but also about the origin of language (likewise the Biblical story about the Tower of Babel). Now, as regards scientific studies of that same subject, one scholarly discourse on the origin of language, affirms what seem to be quite widely held assumptions… the first is that “language disappears on the air as soon as it’s produced, it doesn’t get left behind”, the second is that “humans are the only beings that have language” [3].
That second statement, that “humans are the only beings that have language”, seems, in my opinion, highly debatable, since improvements in audio and video recording technology continually furnish anthropologists with new insights into subtleties of animal communications, which were previously much less accessible to human study. It was once thought that tool use was a uniquely human characteristic… it isn’t any more, and it seems likely that the equivalent article-of-faith, about animals and language, is likely to go the same way. While it should be stressed that the video in question contains a great deal of excellent material, nonetheless the other statement, that “language disappears on the air as soon as it’s produced”, is just plain false. Modern language retains a wealth of evidence about the forms and origins from which it evolved – just because evidence is hard to read doesn’t mean it isn’t evidence; plus, as I’ve already said, written language is a form of audio recording technology, so the irony of asserting that “language disappears on the air” is that our ability to quote this statement forms part of the evidence that disproves that assertion.
As regards studying the origin of language, the philosopher James Stam is quoted as describing how until recently a “shortage of empirical evidence has led many scholars to regard the entire topic as unsuitable for serious study”, and as describing how in 1866 the Société de Linguistique de Paris “banned any existing or future debates on the subject, a prohibition which remained influential… until late in the twentieth century” [4]. The neurolinguists Morten Christiansen and Simon Kirby described this question as “the hardest problem in science” [5]. Noam Chomsky – who is arguably the most famous and important living philosopher in the world – proposes the theory which suggests that infant language acquisition essentially adds-on, as they’ve been called, “parochial” and so-called “surface” features, to the “deep structure” of language circuits – circuits which hard-wire themselves, during neurogenesis, into the infant brain. Deep structures are said to be more concerned with grammar and syntax than with the audible forms in which those structures find symbolic representation [6].
In terms of evolutionary biology, Noam Chomsky suggested that language emerged as a result of one genetic mutation, in one single prehistoric human, which installed the linguistic faculty in “near-perfect” form, inherited by billions of descendants; in this way, the origin of language is compared to the formation of a crystal, such as that of a snowflake [7][8]… which might all sound wildly far-fetched, however in fact the geometric structures of the proteins found in DNA are, though fantastically complex, are still essentially crystalline. The notion that underlying neural structures are common to all languages, resembles the idea of the “Perfect” or “Divine” language that preoccupied the medieval theologians and mystics discussed by Umberto Eco, and you might recall that it’s the divine language that’s spoken by the character Leeloo in the science-fiction film “The Fifth Element”.
In fact, in terms of empirical evidence, studies of this subject experienced something of a quantum leap after the treatment by speech and language therapists of a single family in Brentford, West London, in the late 1980s. Fifteen members of one family, spread across 3 generations, were diagnosed as suffering a severe speech disorder, Developmental Verbal Dyspraxia, which, by 1998, had been identified as stemming from damage to one specific gene, the Forkhead Box Protein P2, or FoxP2.
The FoxP2 gene has been referred to as “the language gene”, “the grammar gene”, and even as “the creativity gene”. It seems however that such descriptions are all exaggerations, since FoxP2 genes are common in species not thought to have “proper” language, and, according to advice from the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, the apraxia occurs when “children have problems saying sounds, syllables, and words”, because “the brain has problems planning to move the body parts… needed for speech”. So, in other words “the child knows what they want to say, but their brain has difficulty coordinating the muscle movements necessary to say those words” [9]. So, the discovery of the FoxP2 “crystal” (so-to-speak) doesn’t prove one single, dramatic evolutionary break-out point for the origin of language, however, to conclude this talk, it does suggest that studies of the human genome are likely to shed a great deal more light on the origins of language in the near future.
[1] Umberto Eco “The Search for the Perfect Language” Fontana 1995
[2] Disinformation “National Grid”, “Stargate”, “Theophany” Ash 3.2 LP 1996
[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvRtlH-3Asc
[4] James H. Stam “Inquiries into the Origin of Language” Harper Collins 1976
[5] Morten Christiansen & Simon Kirby “Language Evolution” OUP 2003
[6] Noam Chomsky “Aspects of the Theory of Syntax” 1965
[7] Noam Chomsky “Language & Mind” in Lyle Jenkins (editor) “Variation & Universals in Biolinguistics” Elsevier 2004
[8] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Sw15-vSY8E [1:12:30]
[9] http://www.asha.org/public/speech/disorders/ChildhoodApraxia/
Article copyright Joe Banks © 18 Oct 2016
Related
From → Uncategorized